BEYOND POLITICS: THE TRUE COST OF RENAMING ESUT By Odoh Kenneth Nnabuike

Crystal Palace Estate

The announcement by Governor Peter Mbah of his intention to rename the Enugu State University of Science and Technology (ESUT) after Senator Jim Ifeanyichukwu Nwobodo has generated conversations about history, recognition, politics and the legacy of the former governor.

Let me state clearly: Jim Nwobodo deserves honour. His decision to establish a university of science and technology in 1980, barely a decade after the Nigerian Civil War, was a significant contribution to the educational development of the old Anambra State.

His contribution should be recognised, celebrated and preserved in our history.

However, recognising a deserving statesman and renaming an established university are two entirely different things.

I strongly oppose the proposed renaming of ESUT, and I believe that the implications of this decision have not been adequately considered.

The real cost of changing ESUT’s name is not the cost of replacing signboards, printing new letterheads or changing the university’s logo. The real cost will be borne by hundreds of thousands of graduates, academics, researchers and current students who have built their educational, professional and international identities around ESUT.

And this cost could follow some of them for decades.

1. THE FINANCIAL BURDEN ON GRADUATES: WES, ICAS AND INTERNATIONAL VERIFICATION

Let us begin with something that many people may not immediately appreciate.

Thousands of Nigerian graduates seek international opportunities every year. Some apply for postgraduate admissions, professional licensing, immigration, employment and credential evaluation in Canada, the United States, the United Kingdom and other countries.

Organisations such as World Education Services (WES) and the International Credential Assessment Service of Canada (ICAS) require academic credentials to be evaluated and, where necessary, verified directly with the issuing institutions.

These processes are not free.

WES publishes credential evaluation fees starting at US$118 for document-by-document evaluation and US$186 for course-by-course evaluation, excluding additional charges. Depending on the exchange rate, delivery and service required, these expenses can run into hundreds of thousands of naira.

There is also the university’s own charge for processing transcripts and responding to verification requests.

ESUT’s publicly available transcript portal currently lists charges for transcript verification and international transcript delivery. Graduates also encounter separate institutional charges when requesting particular academic documents and verification services. The approximately ₦30,000 verification figure cited in this discussion illustrates the additional financial burden that can arise, depending on the service requested.

Now imagine a graduate who has already spent money obtaining a WES evaluation and paying ESUT to verify their academic records.

The university changes its name.

The graduate subsequently encounters a discrepancy between the name on the certificate, the institution’s current name and the name appearing in external academic records.

An evaluator may require additional clarification or documentary confirmation. The graduate may have to return to ESUT for another verification or clarification letter, pay the applicable university processing charge, and potentially incur additional charges from the evaluation agency if a further assessment, update or report is required.

Consider the financial implications:

* ESUT verification or clarification charges.

* WES evaluation and additional service charges.

* International delivery or document transmission costs where applicable.

* Additional institutional verification requests.

* Repeated administrative processing.

* The cost of time spent pursuing these documents.

For someone already struggling financially, this is not a small inconvenience.

A graduate who has saved for years to pursue an international opportunity should not have to spend additional money resolving an institutional identity problem that did not exist when their qualification was issued.

And this is not limited to WES..

The same concerns apply to ICAS, Educational Credential Evaluators (ECE) and other international credential assessment organisations.

The question is simple: Why should graduates be exposed to additional financial obligations because an established university has been given a different name?

2. THE PROFESSORS AND RESEARCHERS WHO HAVE BUILT THEIR INTERNATIONAL ACADEMIC IDENTITIES AROUND ESUT

This is perhaps the most consequential dimension of the proposed renaming.

ESUT has academics who have spent decades building their scholarly careers. They have published in international journals, established research collaborations, accumulated citations, supervised postgraduate students and developed international academic reputations.

Their institutional affiliation is not an ornamental addition to their publications.

It is part of their academic identity.

A professor who has published 50 or 100 international journal articles under the affiliation of Enugu State University of Science and Technology has built an identifiable research history associated with that institution.

Their publications are indexed in international databases. Their institutional affiliations appear in journal records. Their research contributions are used in institutional evaluations, academic rankings and research performance assessments.

Changing the university’s name introduces another institutional identity into this already established academic history.

The consequences are serious.

3. SCOPUS AND WEB OF SCIENCE: THE POTENTIAL FRAGMENTATION OF INSTITUTIONAL RESEARCH RECORDS

Consider Scopus and Web of Science, two of the world’s major academic indexing and citation databases.

Scopus maintains author profiles containing researchers’ publications, affiliations, citations and co-authors. It also maintains institutional affiliation profiles used to identify and aggregate research outputs.

Web of Science similarly maintains author and institutional records and uses institutional unification processes to connect different affiliation variations.

These are not insignificant databases. They are central to international research visibility, bibliometric assessments, institutional research performance and academic evaluation.

Now consider the implications of changing ESUT’s name.

For decades, researchers have published under:

Enugu State University of Science and Technology, Nigeria.

Future publications may appear under:

Jim Nwobodo University of Science and Technology, Nigeria.

These are two different institutional names.

Although Scopus and Web of Science have mechanisms for recognising institutional name variations, institutional name changes can create attribution and data-matching complications.

Elsevier acknowledges that institutional publication records are grouped through affiliation-matching processes and that there can be uncertainty about whether publications belong together.

Clarivate also acknowledges that institutional unification is an ongoing process requiring the identification and reconciliation of institutional name variations.

The implications include:

* Historical publications potentially appearing under a different institutional affiliation from new publications.

* Institutional publication counts being fragmented.

* Institutional citation statistics being affected by attribution inconsistencies.

* Research output being incorrectly associated with separate institutional records.

* Additional complications in institutional research comparisons and rankings

Let us be precise: an individual researcher’s existing citations do not automatically disappear because their university changes its name. A published paper does not lose its DOI or cease to be citable.

But the institutional attribution of those papers matters enormously.

Where the old and new institutional names are not consistently matched, the university’s accumulated research output and citation performance can be misrepresented.

This is a serious concern for academics who have spent years building the institution’s international research reputation.

Why introduce this unnecessary uncertainty into an established academic identity?

4. THE STRESS ON ACADEMICS WILL NOT END WITH THE INITIAL NAME CHANGE

Imagine being a professor who graduated from ESUT, obtained postgraduate qualifications from other universities, returned to ESUT as a lecturer and spent 25 years building an academic career there.

You have published extensively, supervised doctoral candidates, collaborated with international researchers and participated in academic conferences.

Your publications identify ESUT as your institutional affiliation.

Your professional records identify you with ESUT.

Your international academic collaborators know you through ESUT.

Now the institution changes its name.

You must contend with the possibility of explaining the relationship between the former and current institutional identities whenever questions arise in your professional engagements.

The same issue affects younger academics applying for international fellowships, research grants, postdoctoral positions and academic appointments.

Even when the name change is legally recognised, the administrative systems of international institutions do not necessarily update simultaneously.

Different organisations have different databases, verification procedures and documentary requirements.

This means that the inconvenience may not be a one-time occurrence.

It could resurface whenever an academic or graduate needs to establish the identity of the institution that awarded their qualification or employed them.

The people affected are not politicians. They are academics and graduates trying to advance their careers.

5. WHAT ABOUT ORCID, GOOGLE SCHOLAR, RESEARCH PROFILES AND INSTITUTIONAL EMAILS?

Researchers have built professional identities across several academic platforms.

ORCID, Google Scholar, Scopus, Web of Science and other scholarly platforms help researchers establish their publication histories, affiliations and academic visibility.


A university name change does not automatically destroy these profiles. However, it introduces another layer of institutional affiliation information that must be correctly represented.


The same applies to institutional email addresses.


Thousands of academics and graduates have established professional relationships using ESUT email addresses and the university’s institutional domain.


A change of institutional identity raises questions about the continuity of these addresses, professional correspondence and access to institutional systems.


For researchers, institutional email addresses are sometimes used to establish academic affiliation, access journal platforms, register for conferences and communicate with international collaborators.


These are real professional considerations, not cosmetic matters.


6. THE PSYCHOLOGICAL AND EMOTIONAL COST ON GRADUATES


We should also consider the emotional dimension.


People identify with the institutions from which they graduated.


They have certificates bearing the university’s name. They have attended reunions, built professional networks and introduced themselves as ESUT graduates for years.


Some have spent decades promoting the university’s reputation.


The ESUT identity is part of their personal and professional history.


A university’s name is not simply a political label that can be changed without consequences for the people associated with it.


For some graduates, the name change may create confusion when presenting their qualifications. Others may have to repeatedly explain that the university formerly known as ESUT is now called something else.


These may appear to be minor inconveniences to those making the decision, but they are additional burdens on people who have already completed their education and moved on with their lives.


7. THERE IS A BETTER WAY TO HONOUR JIM NWOBODO


My opposition to renaming ESUT should not be interpreted as opposition to honouring Senator Jim Nwobodo.


Far from it.


He deserves recognition for establishing an institution that has contributed significantly to educational development in our region.


But there are other institutions and landmarks that can carry his name without imposing these consequences on ESUT’s graduates and scholars.


The Enugu State Government could consider the State University of Medical and Applied Sciences (SUMAS), the proposed University of Agriculture in Uzo-Uwani or Ohodo Federal Polytechnic, subject to the necessary legal and institutional approvals.


Any of these could become a lasting tribute to the distinguished statesman.


There are also hostels, auditoriums, faculty buildings, research institutes, stadiums and other major university facilities that could be named after him.


A Jim Nwobodo Institute of Science and Technology, for example, could become an enduring monument to his contribution to education.


These are meaningful forms of recognition.


We must not create a problem for hundreds of thousands of people when other avenues of honouring the same individual exist.


8. NNAMDI AZIKIWE: AN EXAMPLE WORTH CONSIDERING


There is a particularly instructive example in our own educational history.


Dr Nnamdi Azikiwe was instrumental in the establishment of the University of Nigeria, Nsukka (UNN), which was founded in 1960.


Yet, another university, Nnamdi Azikiwe University (UNIZIK), was named in his honour in 1991.


Nigeria did not have to rename the University of Nigeria to recognise the contribution of one of its founding fathers.


UNN retained its historical identity, while another institution carried Zik’s name.


Today, both institutions exist with their distinct identities.


That is a practical demonstration that honouring a statesman does not require dismantling or replacing the established identity of an institution.


Jim Nwobodo deserves honour. But ESUT also deserves to retain its identity.


9. THIS IS NOT A DECISION THAT SHOULD BE REDUCED TO SENTIMENT OR POLITICS


I find it troubling that a decision with such far-reaching consequences could become a subject of political excitement without sufficient public examination of its implications.


The fact that the proposal reportedly originated from an alumni association does not automatically make it beneficial to every graduate, academic and stakeholder.


The university belongs to a much larger community than the individuals who initiated or endorsed the proposal.


It belongs to the graduates whose certificates carry its name, the academics whose research is associated with it, the students currently enrolled, and the generations yet to come.


These people have legitimate interests in the university’s identity.


We cannot ignore their interests in the name of celebrating one individual.


The question should not be whether Jim Nwobodo deserves recognition. He does.


The question is why that recognition must come at the expense of an established institutional identity and potentially impose additional financial, administrative and professional burdens on hundreds of thousands of people.


Why should an ESUT graduate pay again and again to establish that the institution from which they graduated is the same institution that has existed for decades?


Why should a professor’s international academic identity be exposed to unnecessary institutional affiliation complications?


Why should someone seeking international admission or professional recognition have to spend additional money and time resolving questions arising from a name change they never requested?


Why should an institution’s accumulated academic identity be subjected to this level of disruption when other ways of honouring its founder are available?


MY POSITION IS CLEAR: STOP THE RENAMING OF ESUT.


Let Jim Nwobodo be honoured.


Let his contributions be documented in our history.


Let his name be immortalised through another university, a major research institution, a faculty, an auditorium, a stadium or a substantial scholarship endowment.


But let ESUT remain ESUT.


We should not sacrifice the institutional identity, professional convenience, financial resources and accumulated academic reputation of hundreds of thousands of people in pursuit of a tribute that can be achieved through other means.


Public recognition should not become a private burden imposed on ordinary citizens.


A statesman’s legacy should be celebrated without making generations of graduates and scholars pay the price.


Beyond politics, we must think about the people.


STOP THE RENAMING OF ESUT.


By Odoh Kenneth Nnabuike

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post